Gays and the military: Joseph Steffan versus the United by Joseph Steffan, Marc Wolinsky, Kenneth S. Sherrill, Richard

By Joseph Steffan, Marc Wolinsky, Kenneth S. Sherrill, Richard B. Cheney, United States District Court (DST), Kenneth S. Sherrill

"Gays and the army: Joseph Steffan as opposed to the U.S." is edited through Marc Wolinsky and Kenneth Sherrill. of their creation the co-editors word that this anthology includes "the most vital parts of the courtroom list from a case referred to as _Joseph C. Steffan_ v. _Richard Cheney, Secretary of Defense_." in addition they notice that Steffan used to be compelled to surrender from the USA Naval Academy after confirming that he used to be gay; the litigation started in 1988.

Some of the files incorporated during this publication are really attention-grabbing. A memorandum in aid of precis judgment for Steffan reproduces a few outrageous charges opposing racial integration and equality within the naval companies within the Forties. student John Boswell contributes an illuminating affidavit reading the background and use of the epithet "homo"; this piece is a reaction to the pass judgement on utilizing this epithet in connection with Steffan. Robert Rankin, a professor of psychiatry with 21 years of military provider, deals testimony demonstrating "that homosexual women and men have served within the usa armed prone all through their heritage and in each armed clash with contrast and in immense numbers." one other fascinating affidavit records different countries' inclusive rules in the direction of gays within the army. Of specific value is pass judgement on Oliver Gasch's 1991 opinion.

Along the best way the individuals cite a few correct stories, in addition to a couple of comparable situations: _ben-Shalom_, _Dronenburg_, _Watkins_, and so forth. The items conceal many matters pertaining both at once or in a roundabout way to Steffan's case: the difficulty of gay orientation being "separate and distinctive from gay conduct"; using "aversion surprise remedy" in makes an attempt to alter sexual orientation; democracy and the idea that of the "tyranny of the majority"; anti-gay violence; the relevance of sodomy legislation; and so on. the most fascinating passages examine parallels among therapy of gays and remedy of different certain teams; for instance, a case debating even if the army can restrict the donning of yarmulkes is mentioned.

This publication encompasses a dense physique of evidence and citations. every now and then the language could strike a few readers as mind-numbingly technical. yet at its such a lot remarkable the contributions contact deeply at the human concerns on the middle of this situation. _Steffan_ is unquestionably an incredible case, and this ebook is a really necessary window into it. additionally advised: "Honor Bound," Steffan's personal well-written memoir of his Academy days and felony struggle.

Show description

Read Online or Download Gays and the military: Joseph Steffan versus the United States PDF

Best civil rights books

Free Speech on Trial: Communication Perspectives on Landmark Supreme Court Decisions

Describes landmark unfastened speech judgements of the very best courtroom whereas highlighting the problems of language, rhetoric, and conversation that underlie them. on the intersection of communique and primary modification legislation live major questions: what's the speech we should guard, and why should still we guard it?

Meaning in Law: A Theory of Speech

Regardless of frequent admiration for the 1st Amendment's safeguard of speech, this iconic function of yank felony concept hasn't ever been properly theorized. current theories of speech continue at the foundation of criminal doctrine and judicial decisionmaking, social and political philosophy, or criminal and highbrow historical past.

Empowerment and Disempowerment of the European Citizen

This assortment engages with a valuable topic on ecu citizenship - the emancipation of sure electorate, the alienation of others - and expands the horizons to interrogate no matter if related debates and traits might be pointed out in different fields of eu integration. the focal point of the booklet is pretty citizen-focused.

Media and Social Justice

This ebook is an anthology of labor by means of serious media students, media makers, and activists who're devoted to advancing social justice. issues addressed contain yet aren't constrained to foreign media activist initiatives akin to the appropriate to verbal exchange stream and its corollaries; the significance of listening and enacting rules that strengthen democratic media; neighborhood and native media justice tasks; explorations of the demanding situations the period of participatory media pose to public media; formative years and minority media tasks and activism; moral dilemmas posed via makes an attempt to democratize entry to media instruments; the continuing marginalization of feminist views in overseas coverage venues; software program freedom and highbrow estate rights; video activism in either old and modern contexts; web thoughts for protecting dissenting voices; and 5 debts through renowned scholar/activists in their lifelong struggles for media justice.

Extra resources for Gays and the military: Joseph Steffan versus the United States

Sample text

The Marine Corps has a special task in connection with landing forces in foreign countries and this is generally done on the briefest notice. There are a number of countries where the landing of Negro Marines would create an extremely diYcult situation and would go far to prevent such use of Marines in the future. ] In 1942, the General Board of the Navy conducted hearings on the question and again concluded that the need for worldwide deployability justified the exclusion of blacks: Admiral Snyder: .

Gays Have SuVered a History of Purposeful Discrimination. ” Jantz, citing Rowland v. Mad River Local School Dist. (1985) (Justice Brennan, dissenting from denial of certiorari) (“homosexuals have historically been the object of pernicious and sustained hostility”). ” The prejudice to which gays have been subjected is also revealed by the fact that gays, like blacks and Jews, are often the subject of biasrelated violence. See AYdavit of Sherrill, par. 59–66. 2. Homosexual Orientation Bears No Relationship to an Individual’s Ability to Perform or Contribute to Society.

Deference, however, has little, if any, place here. The doctrine of deference that defendants rely on has two sources. The first is that the regulation of military matters is, as an initial matter, committed to the Congress. The second is that military oYcers have unique expertise. The first consideration has no place here, however. 30 were not adopted by Congress but, rather, by administrative action. Indeed, no act of Congress regulates homosexuality per se in any context. ” Deference to the unique expertise of military oYcers likewise has no place here for several reasons.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.45 of 5 – based on 42 votes